Introduction
I’ve been working on an article about the SAFe Program Kanban, and found myself mixing in a number of basic Kanban techniques. As I read through the (overly lengthy) first draft and realised the fuzzy focus being caused by a mix of “Kanban 101” and “Program Kanban”, I found myself reflecting on the fact that a lot of people kind of “fall into Kanban”. The two most common cases I encounter are the dev team that evolves their Scrum implementation to the point that the arbitrary batching mechanism of the Sprint Boundary seems suboptimal and the Agile Release Train (ART) Product Management team taking their first crack at a Program Kanban. For whatever reason, many start to use it without ever understanding any of the basic tools available other than “use WIP limits”.
In this article, I’m going to cover two of the basic Kanban concepts every team should take advantage of and a third which tends to be more applicable for strategic Kanban systems than those operated at the dev team level.
Consider the simple yet very common 2-state Team Kanban below:
When the developer completes story S1, they will signal this by pushing it into Test. However, the system is now lying. The fact that the developer has placed it in test does not mean testing has commenced (the clue lay in the use of the word "pushed").
Consider an alternative:
Now, when the developer completes story S1, they place it in "Dev Done". This sends a signal to the testers that when they are ready, they can "pull" story S1 into Test. If we see a big queue building in Dev Done, we can see a bottleneck emerging in front of Test. If (over time), we discover that stories are spending significant amounts of time in "Dev Done" it should trigger some root cause analysis.
You could also achieve the same effect by making a 4 state Kanban as follows:
However, at the strategic level (or for a Kanban system that crosses team boundaries) we benefit by taking it to another level and defining “Exit Policies”. An Exit Policy is effectively the “Definition of Done” for a single state. Whilst it is up to the team member(s) (or Teams) exactly how they do the work for that state, it is not considered “Done” until it meets the exit policies for the state. These policies should be made visible as part of the Kanban design, and should be subject to review and evolution as part of continuous improvement activities. In the words of Taichi Ohno – “Without standards there can be no Kaizen”.
Doing and Done
One of the simplest improvements you can make to a Kanban is the separation of states into “Doing” and “Done”. This separation enables far more accurate visualization of the true state of a piece of work, adds immensely to the granularity of the metrics that can be derived, and most importantly is critical to enabling the move from "push" to "pull" mindset.Consider the simple yet very common 2-state Team Kanban below:
When the developer completes story S1, they will signal this by pushing it into Test. However, the system is now lying. The fact that the developer has placed it in test does not mean testing has commenced (the clue lay in the use of the word "pushed").
Consider an alternative:
Now, when the developer completes story S1, they place it in "Dev Done". This sends a signal to the testers that when they are ready, they can "pull" story S1 into Test. If we see a big queue building in Dev Done, we can see a bottleneck emerging in front of Test. If (over time), we discover that stories are spending significant amounts of time in "Dev Done" it should trigger some root cause analysis.
You could also achieve the same effect by making a 4 state Kanban as follows:
- Dev
- Ready for Test
- Test
- Ready for Acceptance
Exit Policies
The creator of the Kanban Method (David Anderson) identified 5 core properties of successful Kanban implementations, one of which was “Make Process Policies Explicit”. In designing the states of your Kanban system, you are beginning to fulfill this need by making the key stages of your workflow explicit (and supporting another of the key properties – “Manage Flow”). For the evolving Scrum Team, this is often sufficient as it will be supported by their “Definition of Done” (another explicit policy).However, at the strategic level (or for a Kanban system that crosses team boundaries) we benefit by taking it to another level and defining “Exit Policies”. An Exit Policy is effectively the “Definition of Done” for a single state. Whilst it is up to the team member(s) (or Teams) exactly how they do the work for that state, it is not considered “Done” until it meets the exit policies for the state. These policies should be made visible as part of the Kanban design, and should be subject to review and evolution as part of continuous improvement activities. In the words of Taichi Ohno – “Without standards there can be no Kaizen”.
![]() |
Note the explicit exit policies below each state heading in this Portfolio Kanban |
Avatars
Every piece of information you can add to a Kanban board is valuable in conveying extra information to support conversation and insight. Most teams are familiar with the practice of creating a set of laminated “avatars” for each team member. When a team member is participating in the work on a card, they add their avatar to the card as a signal. Thus, anyone observing a Kanban and wanting to know who is working on a card gets instant gratification. Incidentally, this is for me one of the biggest failure areas of digital Kanban boards. To my knowledge, the only digital Kanban tool that supports multiple avatars on a single card is LeanKit – a very strange condition in a world centred on collaboration :)
Now to extend the concept. There is no reason to restrict avatars to the representation of individuals. If we create avatars for Dev Teams, we can (for example) understand which dev teams are involved in the implementation of a feature on a feature Kanban. Take it up a layer, and we can create avatars for ARTs and other delivery organizations. Suddenly, we can look at a portfolio Kanban and understand which delivery organizations are involved in the implementation of an Epic.
Conclusion
There are many more tips and tricks to creating powerful Kanban visualisations, but these are the three I find myself introducing again and again as I help Scrum teams leverage Kanban techniques and ART Leadership teams implement strategic flow Kanban systems.
Always remember, as +Inbar Oren put it so well, a good Kanban board TALKS:
- Tells
- Always Visible
- Lives
- Keeps it Simple
- Self-explanatory
My summary of 'TALKS' is: a one-eyed donkey running through the workplace should be able to parse your board and spot the anomalies without breaking stride.
ReplyDeleteNo, Blogger, I'm not 'Unknown' :-)
ReplyDeleteA portion of these partners incorporate Target, JC Penney, Abercrombie and Fitch, Gap, and Juicy Couture. Designers incorporate Vera Wang, Calvin Klein, and Marc Johnson. Clipping Path Service
ReplyDeleteThank dude for sharing Kanban Boards design tips. It's so powerful idea. Really impressed. Please join us clipping path service group.
ReplyDeleteThis article covers a few techniques to land more web design and web development jobs in Columbus, Ohio. Web designers in Columbus, Ohio can use these tips and techniques to become successful in web design by getting more jobs from web design companies in Columbus. Web design Auckland
ReplyDeleteAstonishing, astoundingly valuable post I appreciated it and wish to see more posts like that structure this blog, I adored this blog this perhaps helpful to me as I additionally have a Photoshop Clipping path service site where we give all kind of Photoshop services and to give tips on Photoshop a clipping path blog i made is a nice way to learn different tips on photography and illustrations designs.hope to get increasingly valuable post Form this blog😊
ReplyDeleteAmazing, astoundingly important post I valued it and wish to see more posts like that structure this blog, I revered this blog this maybe supportive to me as I also have a Photoshop Clipping path service web site where we give all sort of Photoshop services. Want to get progressively important post Form this blog, Again Thanks a lot😊
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for sharing your informative article. I appreciate it.
ReplyDeleteClipping Path Service || Best Clipping Path service || Image masking
Best Ghost Mannequin Services || Car photo editing || Photo Retouching Service || Color correction || Background removal Service || image editing service
I got too much interesting stuff on your blog. I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! Keep up the good work. Clipping Path Service
ReplyDeleteIf you want to turn on the wireless capability, then you need to follow through some steps. These steps are elementary to follow, and anyone how to turn on wireless capability windows 10 to perform them. However, there are three methods by which you can fix your problem of capability.
ReplyDeleteThe great website and information shared are also very appreciable. Marty Mcfly Denim Jacket
ReplyDeleteI am very much pleased with the contents you have mentioned. I wanted to thank you for this great article.
ReplyDeleteBlade Runner 2049 Coat
Zkteco Bangladesh is a Brandable access control and fingerprint product supplier. They Have many useful access control products like ZKTeco F18 Fingerprint Access Control and Time Attendance Machine. Do you know about zkteco f18 bangladesh? ZKTeco F18 is popular in bd as the name of zkteco f18 bangladesh. it is really nice and high quality.
ReplyDeleteIf you plan higher study in China , you must adhere to certain things. First, you need Prepare Yourself and acquire good knowledge from any trusted agency. I think China campus network Bangladesh can assist you in this case. This agency has been working faithfully for a long time.
ReplyDeleteThe team has good project management skills and utilizes tools to improve the ease of communication during timezone challengeUX design services
ReplyDeleteOur the purpose is to share the reviews about the latest Jackets,Coats and Vests also share the related Movies,Gaming, Casual,Faux Leather and Leather materials available Survey Corps Jacket
ReplyDeleteCarry Bag is a one of the Leading Non Woven Bag Supplier in Bangladesh. We provides Bag Locally & internationally.
ReplyDeleteNice Blog !
ReplyDeleteHere We are Specialist in Manufacturing of Movies, Gaming, Casual, Faux Leather Jackets, Coats And Vests See 8 Ball Jacket
Excellent Blog.
ReplyDeleteI love it. Color Correction Service
Greetings from Foto Masking. Happy to surfing this post
ReplyDeleteInterestingly you write, I will address you'll find exciting and interesting things on similar topics. abstract art Dubai
ReplyDeleteThis was an extremely wonderful post. Thanks for providing this info. First Aid Usmle
ReplyDeleteClean Arabia is a trusted cleaning services provider in Dubai. For any kind of cleaning service whether home cleaning or office cleaning, Clean Arabia is capable to meet your need. Clean Arabia is always ready to make your home or office environment cleaner and healthier.
ReplyDelete